| Pfaff:Pfaff Select 4.0 (Sewing Machine) | | Viewed 1880 time(s) | 1 more reviews for this machine | Review rated Helpful by 1 people Very Helpful by 13 people | | Reviewed by: | iSewQuiltArt | 
| About iSewQuiltArt | | AUSTRALIA | | Member since: 4/4/08 | | Reviews written: 83 | | Sewing skills:Intermediate | | Favored by: 19 people | | sewing machines reviewed: 25 | | Bio: more... | | | Posted on: | 12/4/11 2:28 AM | | Approx price paid: | $649 | | Had this machine for: | 2 weeks approx | | Recommended? | Yes | | Online Merchants: | Amazon.com |  | Features
- Needle Threader
- One step buttonhole
- Free Arm
- Adjustable Stitch Length and Width
- Adjustable Presser Foot Pressure
- Adjustable Needle Position
Find the right Sewing Machine with the Sewing Machine Search Wizard
Discuss Sewing Machines with PR members Sewing Machine Forum | | What iSewQuiltArt likes about this machine This machine is a good basic machine that didn't break the bank and produces a good straight stitch. I have had major problems with a second hand machine I bought specifically for an interstate move whilst we stay in less than secure accommodation, and have discovered that the problems are not fixable and will recur, but have a bunch of work to get done in a short of amount of time. Picked this up purely as a stop gap measure since my storage container won't arrive for some weeks that contains my work machines.
I am a Bernina girl so my standards of expectation for machine performance are high. I don't like working on machines that don't function well and I can't stand machines that feel flimsy or produce terrible stitches. Since I wasn't sure if I will keep this machine at the time I bought it I really didn't fancy investing lots of money into a machine that may be a short term use only machine to get me through my workload whilst I wait for my machines to arrive.
The machine is usually $899 in Australia but on Christmas special price and another $50 knocked off the price since I took the store's demo model, so the price was good for the low end of a mid priced machine. I was glad that I saved some money as I had to buy an open toe applique foot to machine applique with, the foot that comes with a plastic bit at the front between two metal toes offers poor visibility and I really couldnt' see well enough what I was doing for precision machine applique work. But the feet themselves seem well enough made and clip on easily.
I like the vertically positioned bobbin with a seperate bobbin case as the for demands of free motion embroidery and quilting I find this configuration produces a better stitch with fewer tension issues.
The machine is simple to thread and simple to select different stitches by pushing buttons. Multiple buttons can be pushed to produce combinations of stitches for additional benefit.
The manual says some are decorative but I would say that most of the stitches are actually utilitarian stitches, there is a good range of stretch stitches. Which I don't need for my current work but if I keep the machine or give it to my kids to sew with then they could make a T-shirt with no problems. Although there is no pressure foot pressure reduction and I have not sewn on knits to appraise the way in which it handles the various sorts of knits available.
I quite like the IDT function, integrated dual feed that Pfaff is known for. No slipping on the fabrics I have been using- cottons and linens to date.
I like that the machine has a solid base and is very stable at high speeds of sewing considering that the machine is lightweight.
The top flap folds up and down with the thread inside so once you are done for the day, the thread is protected from dust. I like I can wind a bobbin through the needle and not have to unthread totally to wind a bobbin and then rethread again to start sewing.
Bobbins wind for me so far nice and firmly, better than the previous Pfaff I owned a few years ago which was a QE4 that had multiple design based issues and which I sold after having problems fixed.
This machine has presented none of the same problems.
I like it is fully manual. Good when I may give it to my kids, and good to save money at a time when I didn't plan to buy a machine but needed to. The dials are a little stiff but should loosen up with some use.
The machine produces a decent satin stitch for a mechanical machine. There are also 40 stitches included. Some are very similar to eachother. All the basic constructions stitches and a few decorative stitches are included.
The machine came with some bonus feet, a darning foot, a rolled hem foot and a fancy stitch foot. Other feet are general purpose foot, zipper foot, blind hem foot and buttonhole foot.
The Select 4 has a well organised front accessory box with a spot for each foot and a lift out organiser that feet sit in. Underneath you can store larger or longer things like screw driver, spare needles etc.
I nearly bought the 3.0 as it was a little less expensive but it lacks the needle threader which is something I love having and with frequent changes of colour when producing art quilts find totally indespensible. It isn't as reliable as the needle threader on my Berninas have proven to me but it does work. There is a chance that any failures that happen are a co-ordination thing as the machine is very different to what I am used to using and feels different.
Lots of needle positions available meaning I didn't need to buy a quarter inch foot, I just move the needle across. Fabric feeds ok and doesn't pull too much to one side, but does pull a little even with IDT on. I also have to remember to shift the needle back and remeasure each time I want to use a scant quarter inch seam, or I find the needle is of course not centred next time I turn the machine on, since it is a fully manual machine so the needle is where ever I left it last time I used it.
I have been appliqueing, piecing, and hemmed a pair of medium weight linen pants and a pair of chino weight drill pants. The machine did take a few smaller stiches over the bulkier seam that my Berninas do not, there is no loss of power but the feed needs assistance with a hump jumper or additional assistance by slightly pulling on the fabric to get the machine to sitch over the bumps. So my thoughts are the needle penetration is good but the feeding isn't quite as nice as on my Aurora 440. Of course there is a huge price difference there of thousands though.
The work surface is comfortable although I think I prefer a flat bed to a curved front.
The stitch plate is easy to pop off but you do need a screw driver or other pointy object to pop into two holes to lever the plate off. Machine is non oiling and easy to clean out.
Machine runs smoothly wth no dramas.
Foot pedal has a curved area at the back for resting your heel on between sewing bouts, its quite comfortable.
Machine design is quite sleek and modern and the multi toned purple front is in no way distracting, its a pretty shade of deep lavender.
There certainly are things that annoy me, read on below, but they are of little significance for me for the long term use I would have of this machine if I decide to keep it.
On balance though I do think this is a nice little workhorse that gets the job done for a reasonable price and doesn't sacrifice stitch quality to do so. Feet are smooth and well made and work, even if I find them harder to see what I am doing for some jobs. For normal piecing or sewing of seams they are absolutely fine. I appreciate the nice bit of grunt the engine offers to penetrate multiple layers of fused applique and stitching through some bulk at seam intersections in garments or quilts. And it is nice to have an IDT capable machine for the price paid. I could see this being very useful when sewing on silk or slippery lining fabrics.
Although there are some limitations for a machine priced around $900 at full price, it is in no way a bad machine, but I do tend to feel for the limitations it has to a quilter or embroiderer, if you are considering it look for it at a reduced price because you may need to buy additional feet for applique if you want to see what you are doing and you may decide to pull a Patsy Thompson on the ankle and slice a duplicate up!
The machine has in no way changed or reduced my love and appreciation of my Bernina machines - not in the same league- and in the long run once I get my container of stuff delivered from our move, I am not sure if this is a machine I will keep or rehome. It is filling a short term gap for me. But I would say for what it is designed to do that so far I have had no real problems with the machine achieving those things. What iSewQuiltArt does not like about this machine Hmmm, the design of the ankle and some feet leave quite a bit to be desired compared to Bernina machines I use that have outstanding design of feet and the offset ankle for their feet for embroidery and quilting.
The Pfaff ankle sits down low, behind the darning foot, and obstructs a lot of vision when working backwards. I am surprised they do not make an alternate ankle to overcome this. I saw once Patsy Thompson in an online video sliced through her ankle to remove the offending part where the foot clips on,pe of the darnning foot which is rectangular. I do think this would be necessary if you planned to buy a Pfaff and to do a lot of freemotion work with any degree of precision. The actual darning foot is made of plastic in that area and it is quite thick which can distort vision. I find this less than ideal. But since I see this machine as a machine to meet a temporary need at at that pricepoint it was my best bet for a decent stitch quality, I put up with it. It does annoy me but I do think if I decide to keep it it would be more for the dressmaking side of sewing than for quilting or for the kids use. I think for that foot design limitations I am experiencing right now would be less likely to come into play. At the end of the day the other feet are designed well enough to offer function that is needed for things like zig zag satin stitching, blind hem, zipper application - the sorts of things you do often when sewing clothes.
There is a half down position for freemotion work that I am still getting my head around, it leaves the foot in a half up position which can for freemotion embroidery produce some wiggly stitches as the fabric can tend to flag up the needle. I do prefer to have my foot closer to my working surface for freemotion work rather than have no ability to adjust the height of this foot with the set up Pfaff have chosen to employ in these and some of their other machines from what I have seen from quilting friends. It is irritating to have stitches be wobbly when I am highly skilled in freemotion work and know it is not anything I am doing different to my usual working style, it is absolutely the machine producing the difference in stitch quality.
The tension dial is a little awkward to alter, it is a little tight and sits in a strange angle in the front of the machine.
The last guide above the needle is a very tight space and I have found that many of the specialty threads I run with success in my other machines can shred at that point. The little metal clip is very tight and it is annoying when threading things like rayon or fine cottons to find they snap whilst "flossing" the thread into place as the manual suggests you do. Once you manage to get the thread in there though things work well enough.
One thing- and bear in mind this machine is built to a certain pricepoint, and built in China, the area surrounding the hook and the little spindle on which the bobbin case sits are plastic. I have no idea how long this will last. I do like machines that have as much metal as possible in this area as I tend to hammer my machines. Although of course I am aware that not all plastic is bad and that there are certainly durable sorts of plastics around...I am just not sure what sort of plastic there is in the bobbin area. Something to consider seriously if you are a constant sewer who sews for hours at a time.
Be aware the buttonhole is manual but has one of those sliding buttonhole feet. Although there are different buttons to press for the different stages, you must set and alter the stitch width and length as required. I am spoilt and do like my automatic buttonholes for things like making shirts where I make buttonhole after buttonhole and want them all exactly the same. Buttonhole capability was completely irrelevant to me for purchasing this machine however as I do not need to produce a buttonhole on my work samples for quilting.
Lighting is OK, but could be better. A second bulb on the inside of the harp near the right side of the needle would be worth having to reduce shadowing. Consider I am totally spoilt with CFL or LED lighting in my work machines however. I think the existing lighting is sufficient for me to work by but if I do a lot of night sewing then additional lamps would be useful.
On balance the negative things for me can be worked around or may become less important to me if I do decide to keep it in the long term. Which if I do would be used to have on the side for fun dressmaking and do not make buttonholes on it. It may be destined for the kids to use if not or I may sell it on. However, I just don't see any reason to fuss around with making manual buttonholes when my other machines make absolutely gorgeous buttonholes automatically or with minimal fuss. That's why the machine being totally manual is not a deal breaker for me but it might be for you if you don't really love making manual buttonholes. | *LOGIN to add a comment to this review *Only registered members can post comments to the reviews. Membership is free. if you are not a member, please Sign-up now! |
|
| Reader Comments | | PortlandMaine | 12/4/11 | I agree wih so much of what you said about this machine - on both sides. Esp the "deco" stitches. I gather there is some kind of a "button" on the foot of the pedal that will limit the amount of play in the foot - giving the user a speed controll. | | * * * | | sew2006 | 12/4/11 | Great review of your machine. If you decide you like this machine enough to keep it, they have a foot 820280096 The creative embroidery foot on p 67 of the download manual. It was made for their embroidery machines, the bottom is a very small metal circle. Your machine has a mezamine level, when putting the foot down for free motion you push back on the lever and it clicks. The foot just hovers evenly above the surface of the fabric rather than a spring loaded foot that goes up/down. | | * * * | | Leorah | 12/4/11 | Great, objective review! Thanks. | | * * * | | Sewing Joe | 12/4/11 | Great review. Very thorough. I have the Select 3.0 and really like it now. | | * * * | | Michele Lommasson | 12/5/11 | Very nice review. | | * * * | | Maia B | 12/5/11 | Another superb, thorough review! I bought a Select 3.0 for a loaner, teaching, and travel machine. I intend to review it soon. Won't be as thorough as this, however. Hope you get established and back to sewing on your Berninas soon :) | | * * * | | iSewQuiltArt | 4/8/12 | So I'm back to my usual and wonderful herd of working machines and decided to sell this off. A friend is going to buy it as her back up machine.
Nothing is amiss with it, I simply prefer my Berninas and it has served its purpose. | | * * * |
|
|