SIGNUP - FREE Membership and 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
| FAQ | Login

Class Reviews > Joyce Murphy’s Pants Fitting Workshop

Viewed 5781 times
Posted by: Tailypo

About Tailypo starstarstar
Member since: 8/6/03
Reviews written: 82
Favored by: 68 people
classes reviewed: 2
Bio: more...
Report a problem with this review
Posted on: 6/8/06 8:27 PM
Rating: starstarstar
Review Rating: Helpful by 2 people   Very Helpful by 13 people   
Once upon a time I decided to start sewing. Thinking that I could purchase a pattern based upon my measurements and then tweak it here and there to come up with a well-fitting pair of pants, imagine my chagrin when I found that the pants I sewed did not fit any better than the ones I purchased off the rack.

So then I found out about Palmer Pletsch patterns, and made a pair of elastic waistband pants that fit me pretty-kinda-okay, having followed their instructions… but I was not exactly sure why it was that they came out okay since the corrections (waistband, repinning the inner thigh) were made to the actual garment, so no markings were on the pattern. The next time I made a pair of pants, they came out just as badly as those I made before the P/P elastic pants. And I did not feel like A) wearing only elastic waistband pants for the rest of my life or B) just kinda guessing about why that pair of pants worked, or why others didn’t.

So then I started reading all sorts of books about fit, and fast fit, and perfect pants. I made various cardboard and tinfoil models of my crotch curve, much to my husband’s amusement, and I followed every pants fitting discussion on PR with great interest. And I tried to make a pair of Hot Patterns pants, and the crotch curve was a disaster, and I could not figure out why.

Then I remembered: I do not give a tinker’s damn about pants fitting theory. I do not care about how to fit a pants crotch or full thigh any more than I care about how to draft a sleeve. I want someone else who cares about those things to hand me a pattern that works for me. Then I want to toss my curls and skip away and sew up something cute.

Which led me to sign up for Joyce Murphy’s Pants Fitting Workshop (with assistance from Judy Barlup, who also wrote the instructions for Joyce Murphy’s pants pattern). First, let me say that Joyce and Judy worked their tails off, and I am in awe of how motivated they are and how hard they work to make sure everyone is getting the attention and information they need. The workshop includes one and a half days of instruction, plus a two hour fitting session during which you are used as a guinea pig for students in a longer course who are learning to fit patterns professionally. The students all write down the measurements as Joyce takes them, and together they discuss what they see and how Joyce will fit your pants. Then off you go while the students toil, and you return another day to try on a paper pattern that a student has drawn up for you under Joyce’s supervision. You look pretty and think about sandwiches while Joyce and the student confer as to what is and is not working, and they perfect your pattern.

You actually get to help out with the drafting by finishing the pocket and waistband pattern pieces, again under Joyce’s supervision. Then off you go, your perfect pattern in hand, confident in the knowledge that you will never buy another pants pattern! And that you must not gain or lose much more than a few pounds for the rest of your life, else risk returning to a world of ill-fitting pants.

As I have already implied, this workshop ran concurrent to another, longer class. This situation created all sorts of problems and I don’t think Joyce will be repeating the format. However, since most of the problems involved lengthy delays, and I utilized each delay by tricking other more experienced students, or Judy Barlup herself, to do things like draft me free bodice slopers, teach me to use a serger, and examine my failed Hot Patterns attempt, I am not complaining, no sir.

…and the lectures were really very edifying, and now I really do understand, to the extent to which I am interested and not a bit more, why my past pants attempts failed and why Joyce’s worked. The pattern I left with is terrific and $150 I spent on the workshop (as time is money, and patterns cost money, not to mention the cost of the fabric etc. that has gone into countless unwearable pants projects…) was totally worth it. Hooray for pants! Hooray for JSM!

ETA: This was not an online class, and I'm not sure how to make that banner under my review title go away.

<< Previous    Next >>

Add Sewing Class Review    Read All Sewing Class Reviews

Login to Add a Comment
GraceGarden said...
Very helpful AND entertaining! I wish I could take the same class!
7/19/08 7:56 PM
jecreates said...
Tailypo; I found this review and found it to be how I felt when I took Joyces class a few years ago. Oh gosh ,how bad is my grammar.Any how good goin. Have fun wiyh next project. Love jecreates
6/18/06 6:17 PM
Carolina65 said...
I would love to take this class. When can I start?
6/14/06 5:03 PM
Seamingly Simple said...
What an entertaining review and marvelous pair of pants. (For those of you who missed them, the pants are reviewed Here). I think we are all envious of your experience. I'm still amusing people with crotch templates and wrapping myself with Saran Wrap!
6/12/06 9:32 PM
Bloom said...
I was so looking forward to 'seeing' your results - would love to know your secrets - as I live so far away, won't be able to do the workshop myself. Any thoughts?
6/12/06 4:56 AM
JDpenelope said...
Cute review (as usual) and valuable information. I share your dis-interest in fitting, but it doesn't get me anywhere. I need this class!
6/10/06 6:54 AM
Stitchology said...
Wonderful story, happy ending. Do they have a website listing where they will be teaching?
6/9/06 4:09 PM
Nancy K said...
Sounds wonderful. Please, please Joyce have a class on Long Island! Pants have been my nightmare for years.
6/9/06 1:17 PM
lornakismet said...
It was fun reading your "story" and I am now very curious about Joyce Murphy's Pants Fitting Workshop. Wow. I'd like to see you in some JM pants. The downside for me is that I am slowly losing the ton of weight that I gained after my husband died....... so whatever they make for me (hopefully) won't be true for too long. Still, I am interested! -LornaKismet (Lorna A.)
6/9/06 1:03 PM
10Ksteps said...
I, too, would take this class in a heartbeat. Thanks for the great detailed review of the process.
6/9/06 11:33 AM
Tailypo said...
Kris, they are reviewed! Take a look over in the pattern review section.
6/9/06 9:25 AM
Kris O said...
What a great review. So when do we get to see these pants?
6/9/06 8:39 AM
BeckyC said...
This sounds like a dream class! If it is ever offered in my town I'd be the first to sign up. Thank you for your review.
6/9/06 8:06 AM
Aixoise said...
OK - I'm inspired. Where do I sign up?
6/9/06 0:15 AM
adv. search»
pattern | machine | member
Online Class
All About Linings
All About Linings

Class Details

Online Class
Understanding Wool Fabrics
Understanding Wool Fabrics

Class Details

You Sew Girl SEWING CLASS 1 - Shopping Bag Pattern

You Sew Girl SEWING CLASS 1 - Shopping Bag Pattern

More Info
Beginner Sewing Lab 101 - A downloadable Book by Shannon Gifford

Beginner Sewing Lab 101  - A downloadable Book by Shannon Gifford

More Info

Conditions of Use | Posting Guidelines | Privacy Policy | Shipping Rates | Returns & Refunds | Contact Us | About | New To PR | Advertising

Copyright © 2014® , OSATech, Inc. All rights reserved.