SIGNUP - FREE Membership and 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
| FAQ | Login
 

Platinum Sponsor
PatternReview.com
PatternReview.com

Forum > Announcements > Reviews ( Moderated by Deepika, Lynnelle)

Please LOGIN or Join PatternReview
Go to Page:
Reviews
Reviews Lacking Content
AngieRose

AngieRose  Friend of PR
Advanced
California USA
Member since 6/1/09
Posts: 329
Send Message

      
thumbsup 4 members like this.



Date: 9/24/13 1:36 PM

Hello Deepika and Lynnelle,

I wonder if you could please consider the content, or lack of content of some members reviews.

If you are monitoring reviews of patterns, sewing machines, servers, books and etc. Could you please consider eliminating product reviews that do not have enough content to make them worth reading.

I joined and pay a membership here, and one of the reasons is the product reviews.

Some are very thorough, while others should not even be considered "reviews" per se.

Thank you for addressing this.


-- Edited on 9/24/13 1:41 PM --
-- Edited on 9/24/13 3:05 PM --

------
AngieRose, who love sewing, machine embroidery and quilting. 2008 Babylock Ellisimo, 2013 Brother DreamWeaver VQ3000, Bernina 1090, Singer Featherweight & 2009 Prodigy Quilter
http://timberhillthreads.blogspot.com

Vicsguy
star
Vicsguy
Advanced Beginner
Ohio USA
Member since 5/17/09
Posts: 224
Send Message

      
thumbsup 25 members like this.



Date: 9/24/13 3:25 PM

Review content is relative and what one considers excellent content may seem like the package back was copied or the writer was doing ad copy for the brand. How one determines what is acceptable content is way too tricky. The simplest solution is read with bated breath those reviews one finds highly valued for content and skip those one sees as not informative to them. I don't think we need content police on PR.

*This post probably falls in the latter to most!

Deepika
starstarstarstar
Deepika  Friend of PR
Intermediate
Massachusetts USA
Member since 11/28/01
Posts: 11885
Founder
Send Message

      
thumbsup 21 members like this.



Date: 9/24/13 4:25 PM

Hi Angie, members write reviews voluntarily and to share their work with others. We do have a minimum limit on the review and we also have suggested templates for most types of reviews but we don't monitor the content. If however the content does not meet our posting guidelines, we do moderate it but as far as the quality of the content goes, its pretty subjective.

Another thing to note is that if a review is helpful, readers are more likely to rate that review and leave a comment as well, which we all love.
-- Edited on 9/24/13 4:35 PM --

------
- Deepika
Founder, PatternReview.com
Blog: http://www.deepikablogs.com

AngieRose

AngieRose  Friend of PR
Advanced
California USA
Member since 6/1/09
Posts: 329
Send Message

      



Date: 9/24/13 7:24 PM

Thank you Vic and Deepika.

------
AngieRose, who love sewing, machine embroidery and quilting. 2008 Babylock Ellisimo, 2013 Brother DreamWeaver VQ3000, Bernina 1090, Singer Featherweight & 2009 Prodigy Quilter
http://timberhillthreads.blogspot.com

bestgrammy
star
bestgrammy
Oregon USA
Member since 8/29/06
Posts: 3556
Send Message

      



In reply to AngieRose <<
thumbsup 3 members like this.


Date: 9/24/13 7:59 PM

A review can be rated as: Needs more info and a comment made as to why you think so then click on save.
Edited a typo
-- Edited on 9/25/13 2:29 AM --

Judy Kski
star
Judy Kski  Friend of PR
Intermediate
Florida USA
Member since 10/26/08
Posts: 1531
online now
Send Message

      



In reply to AngieRose <<
thumbsup 6 members like this.


Date: 9/24/13 9:50 PM

I agree. Some reviews are annoying to read because so little effort has been expended writing them. If someone buys a SM and one week later they decide to review it, is that REALLY enough time to put it through its' paces? Maybe if they are a professional seamstress and have completed a couple garments or a quilt during that timeframe. When someone writes a pattern review and answers the questions with a simple yes or no without some occassional meat and potatoes to go along with their answer concerning the process, what do readers really take away from that review? If we could all just wait until we have enough time on our hands to spend writing an informative write-up, we can all share some valuable information for our readers to learn from.

I have several reviews that still need to be written, but until I can put some dedicated time into making them worthwhile for the reader, they will remain unwritten.
-- Edited on 9/24/13 10:04 PM --

------
Judy

Mufffet
starstarstarstar
Mufffet  Friend of PR
Intermediate
Vermont USA
Member since 8/14/05
Posts: 11178
Send Message

      



In reply to Judy Kski <<
thumbsup 4 members like this.


Date: 9/24/13 10:58 PM

Absolutely. After all, you get points for writing a review, and it is really nice when it is a review.

The issue is not, as has been interpreted above erroneously, the actual content. The issues is the non-review part. Three or four sentences wouldn't be a review if Hemingway were to have written it.

------
"Be kind whenever possible. It is always possible."
--Dalai Lama

I have sewing machines

AngieRose

AngieRose  Friend of PR
Advanced
California USA
Member since 6/1/09
Posts: 329
Send Message

      
thumbsup 3 members like this.



Date: 9/24/13 11:43 PM

I think some members in their excitement decide for whatever reason to post a "Review" of a product they just purchased. It's usually quite brief. A sentence or two of how "excited I am, I love it! It's so nice." and that's the content of the review.
They could have posted their "exciting purchase" remarks on the Message board instead.
I realize we can leave comments about how we perceive a "Non-Review". But, what is the point of that?

-- Edited on 9/24/13 11:45 PM --

------
AngieRose, who love sewing, machine embroidery and quilting. 2008 Babylock Ellisimo, 2013 Brother DreamWeaver VQ3000, Bernina 1090, Singer Featherweight & 2009 Prodigy Quilter
http://timberhillthreads.blogspot.com

andye
andye  Friend of PR
Beginner
Virginia USA
Member since 5/9/09
Posts: 1885
Send Message

      



In reply to Mufffet <<
thumbsup 1 member likes this.


Date: 9/25/13 0:42 AM

I'm in the process of reviewing my sewing library-- I like to think it borders on the esoteric. My strategy so far has been to build a skeleton review and flesh it out if I'm inspired-- or someone shows interest.

Perhaps I'm going about this the wrong way.

------
Bernina B330
Feet: 1,2,3,3A,4,5,7,8,10,13,16,18,20, 29,32,35,37,50,64,70,71,82,85,86, 92

bestgrammy
star
bestgrammy
Oregon USA
Member since 8/29/06
Posts: 3556
Send Message

      



In reply to AngieRose <<
thumbsup 4 members like this.


Date: 9/25/13 1:38 AM

Quote: AngieRose
I realize we can leave comments about how we perceive a "Non-Review". But, what is the point of that?

IMHO...two points for giving a "needs more info" rating and a comment as to why. One is it shows the "reviewer" that others are not informed by the "review" nor as hyped by the sewing machine or whatever as he/she is.

Secondly, getting a "needs more info" or an "off topic" rating...especially multiples of such ratings would decrease or eliminate getting points for the "review".

Conversely, getting helpful and very helpful ratings gets the reviewer more points which add up to getting a star.


Go to Page:
Please LOGIN or Join PatternReview

printable version Printable Version

* Advertising and soliciting is strictly prohibited on PatternReview.com. If you find a post which is not in agreement with our Terms and Conditions, please click on the Report Post button to report it. Announcements >> Reviews

 
adv. search»
pattern | machine | member
        
Online Class
Understanding Knit Fabrics
Understanding Knit Fabrics

Class Details

Online Class
Fun with Fitting - BODICE w Darts
Fun with Fitting - BODICE w Darts

Class Details

Vogue Patterns 1224

photo
by: sewingsill...

Review
New Look 6752

photo
by: lovenicky

Review
Jamie Christina Sunny Day Dress and Skirt Pattern (JC308SD)

Jamie Christina Sunny Day Dress and Skirt Pattern (JC308SD)

More Info
Islander Sewing Systems Irish Coat Pattern Pattern

Islander Sewing Systems Irish Coat Pattern Pattern

More Info

Conditions of Use | Posting Guidelines | Privacy Policy | Shipping Rates | Returns & Refunds | Contact Us | About | New To PR | Advertising

Copyright © 2014 PatternReview.com® , OSATech, Inc. All rights reserved.