Over 20,000 of high quality reorderable fabric
SIGNUP - FREE Membership & 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
Enter your e-mail address:
New to PR?
Compare Sewing Machines
Sewing Machine & Serger Reviews
Sewing Class Reviews
Sewing Expo Reviews
Sewing Tips & Techniques
Sewing Review Requests
Add a Review Request
Friends of PR
Join Friends of PR
Find a member
Add a Classified
reviews with comments
returns & refunds
Platinum Sponsor -
3434 (Misses Tops)
6 more reviews
by 4 people
by 14 people
Member since: 11/28/01
Report a problem with this review
11/25/06 6:20 PM
See other patterns in this category:
To read this review, please
. Only registered members can read reviews written more than 6 months ago.
Pattern with more than 5 reviews!
Merchants on PR
Lanetzliving Vintage Sewing Patterns
Vintage Sewing Patterns
Style Arc sewing dress patterns
Patterns That Fit
Victoria Jones Collection
Timeless Hawaiian styles
Login to Add a Comment
Actually, I think this looks really great on you, but I understand how if one has a waist, you'd want to show it off!! :-)
11/25/06 6:23 PM
Personally, I think it looks good, too. I wonder that when you shortened the top some it makes those gathers hang right on your waist. In the pattern pic, they hang lower. I think the style of the whole top is to hang longer on the body. But I think your "version" looks fine. Question: Is that really YOU in that pic? You look so young!!
11/25/06 6:31 PM
It looks fabulous from the front, but I see what you mean in the closeup. I think you would have to shorten the fronts a lot to eliminate the sagging, but then you would have a different design. I'm glad you have found a little time to sew!
11/25/06 6:45 PM
I think this style hides Deepika's darling figure, so I labeled it a "what not to wear" for her. Now, on ME, it would cover a multitude of sins....if it were about 48" longer. As cute as it looks on the envelope and in KS' photo, I think this is a tough one to wear in real life. Thanks, Deepika. One less pattern on my long wish list...
11/25/06 6:54 PM
Dee: I think you are too much of an hour glass for this style. I think it only would look good on tallish pencil shaped people. That said, for a style that's not soo good, it's really not all that bad.
11/25/06 6:56 PM
I don't see anything wrong with it, either, but if you aren't comfortable in it, then you were right in letting it go. I made the long-sleeved version and love it, but then I have that "multitude of sins" to hide that Karla referred to. Hee.
11/25/06 7:29 PM
I disliked this style in the 80s in its first incarnation for exactly the same reason. I don't think it's ever exactly flattering on an adult woman. It's just an awkward proportion and shape...I remember trying it on back then...when I was a tall, underweight and curveless 20-something and my sister told me I looked like a shirt on a stick. I'm not sure who it works for.
11/25/06 7:46 PM
I think the top looks great on you too. I think the lines from the V-neckline are very slenderizing along with the plaid being at a diagonal. But I certainly wouldn't be happy having a kangaroo pouch at my waist either!
11/25/06 7:52 PM
It looks really fabulous except for waistline....which doesn't look all that bad to me, but I realize it probably doesn't flatter as it should. I hope you have some more of that fabric, because it looks great on you!
11/25/06 7:55 PM
Deepika, I think it looks good as well, but I do agree with you about the kangaroo pouch. I can't see a way round it either - I think it is probably just a 'feature' of the style. On the plus side, be grateful that being so slim, you have nothing to put in the pouch! I had ben thinking about making this but I can only imagine what it would look like on me so I'll pass now. Thanks for the review - you have saved me from certain disappointment :)
11/25/06 7:59 PM
I think Yoda, er, I mean, Karla, has said it all well. Indeed there are projects that are just plain disappointing. I've admired this style on others (yours included), and I've wondered how I'd feel wearing it. Your review has given me some very helpful food for thought. Sorry you were let down, and I hope your next project is much more satisfying.
11/25/06 8:42 PM
Deepika, my first impression by clicking on the photo was WOW !!! The overall look and your fabric choice are beautiful. I have seen a lot of RTW tops with joey's pouch look. Thanks an excellent review.
11/25/06 8:55 PM
You look really nice in your drop waist top despite the pouch. My reaction was the same as Vonnevo's--I thought you looked really great! As someone said, can you make something else with this same fabric or get some more of it? The fabric is really flattering on you.
11/25/06 9:04 PM
Deepika, thanks for this review! I have the pattern & a fabric I will use as a test/muslin. One other review for this pattern mentions a pouchy effect. I'm probably too short for this one to really be flattering & my really tiny waist deserted me years ago. *However*, having said all that, in Oregon this time of the year we take "layering" very seriously! I'm just dying to try this & I will find a way to post a photo & a review. (There's got to be a way!)
11/25/06 10:28 PM
I think it's really cute and even the RTW version of this style top fits the same way. We are our worst critics and if you hadn't pointed that out, I wouldn't have ever noticed. Still very cute!
11/25/06 10:45 PM
I thought it looked great too until I saw the close-up. Sorry the style didn't work for you. Nice fabric though.
11/25/06 11:12 PM
11/25/06 11:13 PM
MelissaB in WA
Bummer it didn't work out for you. I had one of those projects last weekend and still need to review it. It is always so sad when we take time to make something that we don't care for or doesn't flatter my figure. Oh well, that is just how it goes sometimes.
11/26/06 0:08 AM
Deepika, you really good in this top! A wadder, I do not think so!
11/26/06 0:39 AM
I think the top looks good on you. In looking at the model wearing this one, she too has that "kangaroo pocket" as you call it. I really think that is the intended look. Nonetheless, I bought the same pattern but kept thinking about that poochiness at that area. Not sure if you shorten it if it would help or not. Again I think it looks good on you and probably most people see you from a frontal view more than side.
11/26/06 7:40 AM
Deepika - for what it's worth I think it looks great - it is meant to pooch at the front - lots of RTW showing this style. However, if this is not something you feel good in then I guess it is up to you to call the wadder!! I definitely won't try it as I do not have the nice figure you have!!
11/26/06 8:53 AM
I'm sorry you don't like this top on you. I think it looks great, and you're so slim that no one would ever mistake the "kangaroo pooch" for your actual body. ;-) But I understand how disappointing it is when a finished garment doesn't match our expectations.
11/26/06 9:16 AM
I have this one lined up. I am thinking you also have to be very tall at least through the torso to pull this one off. I also think these tops are great for slinky, which probably not do that pooch thing. Thanks for the warning.
11/26/06 9:43 AM
Cute, definitely wearable even though not your best style. (It wouldn't work for me either.)
11/26/06 9:52 AM
Thanks everyone for your nice comments. To be honest if my husband didn't dislike this look so much, I would have at least worn it to the gym or at home on the weekends in summer. I think it's a cute style. and its comfortable too.
11/26/06 10:51 AM
This looks great on you. I think maybe you are not used to the silhouette? Even the Kwik Sew photo has a bit of drape in the same place. Sometimes projects that don't seem right just need a bit of time to get used to.
11/26/06 5:53 PM
When I first looked at the picture, I thought it looked great on you. Only when you pointed it out, was the "kangaroo pouch" noticeable. I think it's a keeper.
11/26/06 6:22 PM
I agree it does look good on you. I suppose because it did not turn out how you envisioned you are disappointed?
11/26/06 9:55 PM
Looks great, wear it when DH is not around:-)
11/27/06 3:50 AM
Wear it when DH isn't around. It's cute on you and looks really comfortable (always a good combo).
11/27/06 10:29 AM
Deepika, I just wanted to add that I agree this top looks wonderful on you, especially the fabric. I too hope you have more of it or can get more. The empire version of this pattern would be great on you -- much more flattering!
11/27/06 10:55 AM
Deepika, I think it looks adorable on you. I understand that the pouch is
'out there' but it still looks really cute.
11/27/06 5:33 PM
I have only recently bought this pattern, hence my late comment. Personally, I like the top on you and the gathered draped droopy bottom is exactly as it's shown on the drawing and is how I imagined it would look. It's a shame you thought it was a wadder.
7/30/07 9:55 PM
Online Sewing Classes
Clone Your Favorite Garment
Online Sewing Classes
Sew a Designer Unlined Jacket
Burda 7246 Pattern
Add to Bag
McCalls 6097 Pattern ( Size 6-8-10-12 )
Add to Bag
Vogue Patterns 8594
You Sew Girl USB Fob Digital Pattern
Add to Bag
Blank Slate Perfect Polo Digital Pattern
Add to Bag
THE SKIRTS - A CD Book By Kenneth King
Add to Bag
Sew Liberated Reading Pillow
Add to Bag
Copyright © 2014 PatternReview.com® , OSATech, Inc. All rights reserved.
Conditions of Use