Online Sewing Class: All About Linings
SIGNUP - FREE Membership and 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
| FAQ | Login

Pattern Reviews> McCall's> 5278 (Misses' Jacket w/ Shawl Collar)

2 more reviews
Viewed 1006 times 
Reviewed by:Dr. Alice
photo

 
 
About Dr. Alicestar
MA USA
Member since: 1/5/04
Reviews: 22 (patterns: 22)
Skill level:Beginner
Favored by: 12 people
more...
Report a problem with this review
Posted on:1/20/07 3:38 PM
Last Updated:1/20/07 3:41 PM


Review Rating: Helpful by 4 people    Very Helpful by 11 people   
To read this review, please Login. Only registered members can read reviews written more than 6 months ago.

Merchants on PR

Reconstructing History


Historical Patterns
Web site

O! Jolly! Shop


Sweater knit fabrics
Web site

Elliott Berman Textiles


Fabrics for Greater Ideas
Deals!

<< Previous      Next >>
24 Comments      Login to Add a Comment
Katharine in BXL said... (2/10/07 4:06 AM) Reply
That is one sharp jacket on you! I can't believe it's jacket #2. From here in Belgium I can't see the fabric is cheap (consolation?)
SewTwin said... (1/29/07 1:15 AM) Reply
You did great if this is only your 2nd jacket!The jacket looks better than most Nieman's I've seen.Probably fits better than RTW,too. I think you actually made inexpensive fabric look expensive.Isn't that what some designers do?
AnneM said... (1/28/07 8:24 PM) Reply
Great top, what a nice style. Good fabric is worth using (although your jacket certainly looks nice in the pictures).
nicegirl said... (1/22/07 4:46 PM) Reply
I really like that style! And the color! Good job.
BeckyC said... (1/21/07 10:14 AM) Reply
Your jacket looks fabulous on you! You did a wonderful job! If you can bag a lining and realize you need extra length for movement, you'll be able to master bound buttonholes in a snap! Great review.
krystalkaes said... (1/21/07 8:25 AM) Reply
Nice jacket and beautiful smile.
PixieCat said... (1/21/07 5:46 AM) Reply
Beautiful jacket and such a flattering style on you! Nice job.
Tany said... (1/21/07 4:46 AM) Reply
I love it! Very well done on your second jacket!
Nancywin said... (1/21/07 2:31 AM) Reply
Very nice,and does not look cheap in the pics. I think I see what you're talking about in the collar though. Sometimes using a higher end interfacing CAN make a "cheap fabric look expensive" ;-) Nice review - and nice jacket!
quiltsammon said... (1/21/07 1:54 AM) Reply
Beautiful!! Good job!
Patzee said... (1/21/07 1:40 AM) Reply
I think you have progressed beyond beginner. I know this because I am a beginner!
tweedcurtain said... (1/21/07 1:34 AM) Reply
I agree wtih Karla - yours is MUCH nicer than the pattern envelope. Well done!
Helen near Sydney said... (1/21/07 1:01 AM) Reply
Dr. Alice, you must be thrilled with your jacket, it looks absolutely beautiful and the fabric not at all 'cheap'. I think some hand stitching around the collar, the way you see in high-end menswear would also look good.
Karla Kizer said... (1/20/07 8:12 PM) Reply
I think it looks great - and that McCalls would be wise to substitute your version for theirs on the pattern envelope. Good job!
Sew4Fun said... (1/20/07 7:53 PM) Reply
Lovely jacket. The collar suits you.
Erica B. said... (1/20/07 7:41 PM) Reply
I think the jacket looks great and and the pink lining was a great touch.
HawkeMorningStar7 said... (1/20/07 6:25 PM) Reply
Very chic, nice all around.
suzanrossi said... (1/20/07 5:45 PM) Reply
The jacket is lovely and you look great in it. You've done a nice job! You know, other people hardly ever see the "flaws" we see in our sewing. Most people wouldn't even look twice at a buttonhole, for instance. (By the way, yours look just fine from where I'm sitting)
Jacqui315 said... (1/20/07 5:34 PM) Reply
I have been looking at this pattern. I like it a lot - it has a flattering style.
Re Becca said... (1/20/07 5:24 PM) Reply
I don't think that it looks cheap either. From here it just looks like you got a good deal on a nice jacket. I think that the sewn buttonholes look fine as well. The fabric lays well and apears to have pressed well.
Linda G said... (1/20/07 5:10 PM) Reply
It does not look cheap in the pictures.
LauraTS said... (1/20/07 4:36 PM) Reply
This shape looks great on you; very pretty.
LornaJay said... (1/20/07 4:13 PM) Reply
Lovely jacket - it really seems to suit you.
jnamcd said... (1/20/07 4:09 PM) Reply
Nice job! I love the pink lining!!
 
adv. search»
pattern | machine | member
        
Online Class
Perfectly Fitted Shirt
Perfectly Fitted Shirt

Class Details

Online Class
All About Buttons and Buttonholes
All About Buttons and Buttonholes

Class Details

Decades of Style 3009

photo
by: Sew Good

Review
Pin-up Girls Amanda Foam Cup Bra

photo
by: NhiHuynh

Review
You Sew Girl Fan Bag Pattern

You Sew Girl Fan Bag Pattern

Pattern Details
Veronica Pocketbook Paper Pattern

Veronica Pocketbook Paper Pattern

Pattern Details