SIGNUP - FREE Membership and 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
| FAQ | Login
Platinum Sponsor
Fabulous Fit
Fabulous Fit

Pattern Reviews> Simplicity> 5429 OOP (1970s Juniors/Teens Smock Top)

Viewed 743 times 
Reviewed by:meli88a

About meli88astarstar
Member since: 5/20/03
Reviews: 73 (patterns: 73)
Skill level:Intermediate
Favored by: 42 people
Report a problem with this review
Posted on:3/2/07 10:42 PM
Last Updated:3/2/07 10:42 PM
Review Rating: Very Helpful by 4 people   
To read this review, please Login. Only registered members can read reviews written more than 6 months ago.
<< Previous      Next >>
13 Comments      Login to Add a Comment    
AnneM said... (3/3/07 3:59 PM) Reply
Modern pattern sizing is as bad as modern RTW sizing. Really cute sleeves on this. There is a lot of ease, but you could have handled a FBA to get the front hem lower. The tunic tops are definitely in style, so you don't have to fret about if you look pregnant, since so many people are wearing (more boring versions of ) tunic tops.
Em's Summer said... (3/3/07 3:03 PM) Reply
This is really cute and definitely doesn't look like a maternity top!
SarahWeb said... (3/3/07 10:55 AM) Reply
What a cute top! I am in the camp that says this does NOT look like a maternity top. Way too light and swingy and hip to be taken as such. Wear it with confidence!
Kay Y said... (3/3/07 10:18 AM) Reply
Cute top! Like hejest, I remember this pattern from the 1st time around. I also remember that size range (young jr. teen). By 1972 the pattern companies had switched to the "new" sizing for misses sizes, which is the same set of measurements as today, but the young junior teen 9/10 was not the same as misses 10. Some of the patterns from that era came in both size ranges.
suzanrossi said... (3/3/07 9:03 AM) Reply
Sweet! I think the fabric choice helps this to NOT look like a maternity top.
suzanrossi said... (3/3/07 9:02 AM) Reply
Sweet! I think the fabric choice helps this to NOT look like a maternity top.
LauraM62 said... (3/3/07 8:20 AM) Reply
I see someone else said they actually made this back in 1972 . My thoughts were I made similar tops, back in home ec, learning to sew! They made us do all that hand sewing back then. And the fabrics listed, well your fabric wouldn't have been listed probably because our fabrics were more limited as to what was available to purchase . It has definately gotten better!
meli88a said... (3/3/07 7:25 AM) Reply
hejest, what a funny coincidence!
Tany said... (3/3/07 4:45 AM) Reply
Love it! Well done!
hejest said... (3/3/07 2:00 AM) Reply
I'm so sorry! I forgot to mention how cute yours is! It's fantastic!
hejest said... (3/3/07 1:55 AM) Reply
Would you believe that in 1972 I made this pattern! In fact I made 2 of these smock tops. They were totally IN, and I didn't care about those questions. Mind you they were usually worn with a turtleneck or shirt underneath. It brings back many happy memories.
Helen near Sydney said... (3/3/07 1:46 AM) Reply
This style really suits you.
JenSews2 said... (3/2/07 11:34 PM) Reply
Cute top!
adv. search»
pattern | machine | member
Online Class
Pattern Work
Pattern Work

Class Details

Online Class
Altering Pants
Altering Pants

Class Details

Butterick 5275

by: HDWen

Jamie Christina Sunny Day Dress and Skirt Pattern (JC308SD)

Jamie Christina Sunny Day Dress and Skirt Pattern (JC308SD)

Pattern Details
Sewing Workshop Quincy Top and Pants

Sewing Workshop Quincy Top and Pants

Pattern Details