CarolynGM said... That's a fine looking shirt. Great job! 8/18/09 12:46 PM
cleverkitty said... Ha! I love it love it, right away I said he made it from a sheet!!! I love vintage sheets, use to collect them. Looks like a great fit. Thanks for the review 8/18/09 12:59 PM
lauraborealis said... I love that shirt! 8/18/09 2:31 PM
LynnG said... I remember sewing this pattern for my husband (then boyfriend) when it was new. Looked great then too! Great job and good use of the vintage sheet. 8/18/09 2:58 PM
Mufffet said... Great shirt! Love the pattern photo in the review...I guess they recycled that number! I wish they wouldn't DO that! 8/18/09 3:08 PM
Mufffet said... sigh...dup... 8/18/09 3:08 PM
Nancy Anne said... You and your sheets. :-) Seriously, this turned out fantastic! The only thing I think is harder than a placketed shirt is a placketed shirt with a yoke! I'd rather make a formal gown. Nice job! 8/18/09 3:53 PM
RLL said... Another shirt nicely done. I make all my DH shirts, so I can appreciate all the work that goes into them. 8/18/09 4:47 PM
eugenia123 said... Another really beautiful shirt!! I love that you have combined a Western style with a floral print - it's a great look. 8/18/09 5:28 PM
puddypaws said... Another great shirt Peter. At least I didn't have those sheets. 8/18/09 6:37 PM
Knitters Delight said... Your shirt came out great! 8/18/09 6:56 PM
sew obsessed said... Seriously Peter, you need to change the beginner status. You are 2 for 2 here with the second great shirt in a row with details that are not beginner details!!! I live in cowboy country and I get worn out with all the buttons....I love the timeless look. Great job. 8/18/09 7:26 PM
Enid E said... Great job! I agree , Peter, change your status.
Thanks for the detailed photos...they are inspiring.. 8/18/09 7:59 PM
katharin said... Cool! I love the combination of flowery fabrics and men's shirt, and the shape of the collar looks great. It seems that this pattern has kilometers of topstitching. Great job! 8/18/09 8:06 PM
FreyaStark said... Nice job - a lovely shirt. Well done. 8/18/09 9:25 PM
LollyVee said... Peter, I love your reviews, however they do make me look like an amateur! Nicely done. 8/19/09 1:05 AM
Michele19 said... Congratulations on a great shirt! The style/pattern combo is really cool, lowkey and comfortable. Thanks for the great review esp. tip on updating the older style. 8/19/09 6:17 AM
birdmcfarland said... Outstanding!! If you consider yourself a beginner, you are way ahead of your time! I love the shirt and you look fantstic wearing it! 8/19/09 7:59 AM
AnneMarie60 said... Fabulous job on this wonderful shirt. It fits you very nicely. 8/19/09 8:35 AM
mylittleelephant said... Beautiful collars and lovely slim fit, there should be women version of this shirts! 8/19/09 8:40 AM
nancy2001 said... Another great shirt. Now please change your status to advanced beginner -- you've earned it. 8/19/09 8:52 AM
jilly cooper said... oh my goodness. this is so good. fabric is awesome, and this is your second shirt.....wow ... 8/19/09 9:46 AM
Woolygal said... Men are lucky that they can use the same shirt pattern over and over. You are right, the fitted shirt is great on you. 8/19/09 10:08 AM
lizagm said... Wow, it looks awesome! My husband has been begging me to make him a short sleeve button up. Maybe I too will have to try and track this one down. I love it! 8/19/09 10:55 AM
Peter in NYC said... You folks are great -- thank you for all the positive feedback! As far as being a Beginner or not, this and boxers are the only things I can sew, so let me try some pants and then let's see.
This pattern is currently for sale in a 46 (Chest) on Etsy; I'd check eBay too:
http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=12030494 8/19/09 11:13 AM
Erin S said... Peter, you are totally inspiring me to sew shirts for my husband. He would love your shirt/fabric selection. 8/19/09 11:21 AM
feldmanTcat said... This is a fantastic shirt. My fiance is slim and I used a vintage Simplicity for him - it's the only way I can get shirts to fit him, nothing in stores fits either. Thanks for the tip on other vintage shirts, I may have to track some more down for him. 8/19/09 1:54 PM
layla said... This is a great look on you ... love it !! 8/22/09 7:20 PM
pammieh said... Peter, you do some wonderful wonderful work. The fit is fantastic and I love the dichotomy of the floral pattern on the western style 70s shirt! Great job - you are an inspiration! 8/26/09 10:02 PM
Peter in NYC said... Thanks again everybody. I'm actually away on vacation this week in Provincetown, MA -- wore my shirt to dinner last night -- but can't wait to get home to my sewing machine(s). How twisted is that?! 8/27/09 9:16 AM
cyclegirl said... I love your shirt! I've been trying to talk my husband into letting me make him a western shirt. I hadn't thought of using a vintage pattern for him, he's very slim. Thanks for the review and the tip! 8/27/09 5:33 PM
Mare Mare said... AMAZING sewing skills! FANTASTIC photos! I LOVE all of the detail provided!!! I too enjoy sewing with older patterns. I have patterns that my mother used for my older sister, then on me, then my little sister, her grandaughters...the 'classics' last forever. Now I have a grandaughter and guess what patterns I'm using for her??? They're close to 60 yo but little girl dresses reamin basically the same.
AMAZING job, Peter! I really appreciate your sewing skills!!! 8/31/09 2:42 PM
MBPaz said... Peter - a luau and a rodeo! How versatile! Very well made. Say goodbye to beginner status. 9/1/09 8:02 AM
That's a fine looking shirt. Great job!
8/18/09 12:46 PM
Ha! I love it love it, right away I said he made it from a sheet!!! I love vintage sheets, use to collect them. Looks like a great fit. Thanks for the review
8/18/09 12:59 PM
I love that shirt!
8/18/09 2:31 PM
I remember sewing this pattern for my husband (then boyfriend) when it was new. Looked great then too! Great job and good use of the vintage sheet.
8/18/09 2:58 PM
Great shirt! Love the pattern photo in the review...I guess they recycled that number! I wish they wouldn't DO that!
8/18/09 3:08 PM
sigh...dup...
8/18/09 3:08 PM
You and your sheets. :-) Seriously, this turned out fantastic! The only thing I think is harder than a placketed shirt is a placketed shirt with a yoke! I'd rather make a formal gown. Nice job!
8/18/09 3:53 PM
Another shirt nicely done. I make all my DH shirts, so I can appreciate all the work that goes into them.
8/18/09 4:47 PM
Another really beautiful shirt!! I love that you have combined a Western style with a floral print - it's a great look.
8/18/09 5:28 PM
Another great shirt Peter. At least I didn't have those sheets.
8/18/09 6:37 PM
Your shirt came out great!
8/18/09 6:56 PM
Seriously Peter, you need to change the beginner status. You are 2 for 2 here with the second great shirt in a row with details that are not beginner details!!! I live in cowboy country and I get worn out with all the buttons....I love the timeless look. Great job.
8/18/09 7:26 PM
Great job! I agree , Peter, change your status. Thanks for the detailed photos...they are inspiring..
8/18/09 7:59 PM
Cool! I love the combination of flowery fabrics and men's shirt, and the shape of the collar looks great. It seems that this pattern has kilometers of topstitching. Great job!
8/18/09 8:06 PM
Wonderful looking shirt! Wow!
8/18/09 8:14 PM
Nice job - a lovely shirt. Well done.
8/18/09 9:25 PM
Peter, I love your reviews, however they do make me look like an amateur! Nicely done.
8/19/09 1:05 AM
Congratulations on a great shirt! The style/pattern combo is really cool, lowkey and comfortable. Thanks for the great review esp. tip on updating the older style.
8/19/09 6:17 AM
Outstanding!! If you consider yourself a beginner, you are way ahead of your time! I love the shirt and you look fantstic wearing it!
8/19/09 7:59 AM
Fabulous job on this wonderful shirt. It fits you very nicely.
8/19/09 8:35 AM
Beautiful collars and lovely slim fit, there should be women version of this shirts!
8/19/09 8:40 AM
Another great shirt. Now please change your status to advanced beginner -- you've earned it.
8/19/09 8:52 AM
oh my goodness. this is so good. fabric is awesome, and this is your second shirt.....wow ...
8/19/09 9:46 AM
Men are lucky that they can use the same shirt pattern over and over. You are right, the fitted shirt is great on you.
8/19/09 10:08 AM
Wow, it looks awesome! My husband has been begging me to make him a short sleeve button up. Maybe I too will have to try and track this one down. I love it!
8/19/09 10:55 AM
You folks are great -- thank you for all the positive feedback! As far as being a Beginner or not, this and boxers are the only things I can sew, so let me try some pants and then let's see. This pattern is currently for sale in a 46 (Chest) on Etsy; I'd check eBay too: http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=12030494
8/19/09 11:13 AM
Peter, you are totally inspiring me to sew shirts for my husband. He would love your shirt/fabric selection.
8/19/09 11:21 AM
This is a fantastic shirt. My fiance is slim and I used a vintage Simplicity for him - it's the only way I can get shirts to fit him, nothing in stores fits either. Thanks for the tip on other vintage shirts, I may have to track some more down for him.
8/19/09 1:54 PM
This is a great look on you ... love it !!
8/22/09 7:20 PM
Peter, you do some wonderful wonderful work. The fit is fantastic and I love the dichotomy of the floral pattern on the western style 70s shirt! Great job - you are an inspiration!
8/26/09 10:02 PM
Thanks again everybody. I'm actually away on vacation this week in Provincetown, MA -- wore my shirt to dinner last night -- but can't wait to get home to my sewing machine(s). How twisted is that?!
8/27/09 9:16 AM
I love your shirt! I've been trying to talk my husband into letting me make him a western shirt. I hadn't thought of using a vintage pattern for him, he's very slim. Thanks for the review and the tip!
8/27/09 5:33 PM
AMAZING sewing skills! FANTASTIC photos! I LOVE all of the detail provided!!! I too enjoy sewing with older patterns. I have patterns that my mother used for my older sister, then on me, then my little sister, her grandaughters...the 'classics' last forever. Now I have a grandaughter and guess what patterns I'm using for her??? They're close to 60 yo but little girl dresses reamin basically the same. AMAZING job, Peter! I really appreciate your sewing skills!!!
8/31/09 2:42 PM
Peter - a luau and a rodeo! How versatile! Very well made. Say goodbye to beginner status.
9/1/09 8:02 AM