SIGNUP - FREE Membership and 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
| FAQ | Login

Pattern Reviews> McCall's> 5815 

12 more reviews
Viewed 1231 times 
Reviewed by:elainemay
photo

 
 
About elainemaystarstarstar
Member since: 2/4/09
Reviews: 21 (patterns: 21)
Skill level:Intermediate
Favored by: 94 people
more...
Report a problem with this review
Posted on:9/7/09 6:22 PM
Last Updated:9/8/09 1:44 PM


Review Rating: Helpful by 1 people    Very Helpful by 24 people   
See other patterns in this category: Coat/Jacket    
To read this review, please Login. Only registered members can read reviews written more than 6 months ago.
<< Previous      Next >>
33 Comments      Login to Add a Comment
Nancy Anne said... (8/21/12 4:29 PM) Reply
I am about to make this same jacket in a non-drapey fabric and was concerned about the pockets. Read your review and thought "Duh, Nancy! Just don't put them on!" :-) I think yours looks better without them, anyhow. I also appreciate the tip about tacking the bow down. We live in a windy city on the northern plains of Texas and I'm sure I'd get beat to death by the bow the first time out without it.
Nana2be said... (12/4/09 8:17 PM) Reply
Beautiful work, Elaine! It fits you like a glove. I could see where the bow would blow up and maybe cause you an injury, lol.
lynnewill said... (10/8/09 10:05 AM) Reply
Thank you for the well written review. Appreciate the detailed pattern correction, and the update. The pinstripe was an excellent choice.
cdi9c said... (9/9/09 10:58 AM) Reply
Fabulous with a capital F!
FreyaStark said... (9/9/09 6:27 AM) Reply
It's fabulous and the fabric is delicious (I love brown). Well done. Omitting the pockets was a good idea.
Christas said... (9/8/09 8:37 PM) Reply
Wonderful jacket and wonderful review! I have this pattern. I sure I will come back to this review and use your helpful information. Thanks!
CynthiaSue said... (9/8/09 1:48 PM) Reply
utterly adorable. work chic to going out fun with jeans!! love it.
Stitchcakes said... (9/8/09 11:33 AM) Reply
Yep, the pinstripes take it from dangerously twee Easter jacket to strikingly chic suit with a fantastic interplay of masculine and feminine. Love it!
Sheila457 said... (9/8/09 11:21 AM) Reply
Lovely jacket and great review.
DorothyK said... (9/8/09 10:05 AM) Reply
Fabulous! You did a great job and it looks great on you.
Kellie R. said... (9/8/09 8:54 AM) Reply
Fabulous jacket! I have this pattern and hope that when I get around to making it, it looks as good as yours!
valerie sews said... (9/8/09 8:52 AM) Reply
Your jacket looks totally couture. It fits you beautifully and suits you perfectly. Wow.
Amanda S. said... (9/8/09 8:24 AM) Reply
Love it! I must admit, I've not been a huge fan of this jacket worn as a separate. It's always looked a bit gramma-ish to me. But as a suit it's completely chic! Especially in the pinstripe. I guess I should have looked at the Nanette website - that is how they have their's styled. Anyway, superb job on both pieces.
BillieJean said... (9/8/09 6:01 AM) Reply
Really beautiful. I like this without the pockets too.
lara900 said... (9/8/09 2:14 AM) Reply
very cute jacket, and great review with lots of detailed information. I am building up strength and courage to sew my first jacket, and your jacket is very inspiring. (even if the pattern is too difficult for a beginner)
Allie in Hong Kong said... (9/8/09 1:55 AM) Reply
Gorgeous, perfect fit and fabric choice for your jacket, I love it!
erinw83 said... (9/7/09 10:53 PM) Reply
Great Job! You have such a wonderful sense of style!
rebija said... (9/7/09 10:27 PM) Reply
I saw this pattern the other day and wasn't too sure about it. You've definitely changed my mind! Beautiful job!
Carol Mendoza said... (9/7/09 9:15 PM) Reply
Fantastic Jacket. It looks wonderful on you. Great job!
Michelle L said... (9/7/09 8:59 PM) Reply
Great work! I love it in the stripe. I have made this jacket, too, and you are right...the collar pieces do go together just like a puzzle!
Erica B. said... (9/7/09 8:40 PM) Reply
I love yours in pinstripe! It looks fabulous!
Tiner W said... (9/7/09 7:54 PM) Reply
Stunning!
lilyofthevalley said... (9/7/09 7:36 PM) Reply
Very smart and elegant, and suits your trim figure just perfectly. It gives you both stature and shape. And as always, beautifully sewn. Lovely, Lily
Beek said... (9/7/09 7:32 PM) Reply
I love this style. I made a DKNY jacket pattern very similar to this one for my sister. It is a feminine take on a masculine look (jacket with lapel). Nice review, thanks!
Morisot said... (9/7/09 7:31 PM) Reply
Lovely!
Catbird said... (9/7/09 7:15 PM) Reply
Wow - so pretty! You've done a beautiful job and have made a classic jacket with flair and style. It looks fantastic on you and I hope you enjoy wearing it for years to come!
yoshimi said... (9/7/09 7:10 PM) Reply
Gorgeous jacket. It's very nice on you. Thanks for your great review, I have just put this in my wish list!
ClaireF in CA said... (9/7/09 7:08 PM) Reply
Beautifully made, and gorgeous on you! Thank you so much for pointing out the problems with the collar pattern pieces, as I have this pattern and will watch for that when I sew it up. Great review and pictures!
LynnRowe said... (9/7/09 6:55 PM) Reply
WOW. Elegant, tailored, fitted, fun...you've batted this one right outta the park!!!
HLT said... (9/7/09 6:42 PM) Reply
Very nice jacket! I love the finish of your collar. With the fabric, it looks very couture.
semiscot said... (9/7/09 6:34 PM) Reply
Fantastic, looks great!
Rhonda in Montreal said... (9/7/09 6:34 PM) Reply
Cute! Cute!! Cute!!! Especially in size 4, eh!! VERY nice work!!
ClaireEmily said... (9/7/09 6:28 PM) Reply
This is gorgeous!!! It fits you perfectly. Very chic!
 
adv. search»
pattern | machine | member
        
Online Class
All About Linings
All About Linings

Class Details

Online Class
Put it on the Bias
Put it on the Bias

Class Details

McCall's 5989

photo
by: pinkcatflo...

Review
Islander Sewing Systems Moebius Scarf Pattern

Islander Sewing Systems Moebius Scarf Pattern

Pattern Details
You Sew Girl Zip Away Shopping Bag Pattern

You Sew Girl Zip Away Shopping Bag Pattern

Pattern Details
No Pattern Used 0000

photo
by: Lizz

Review