Pattern Sizing: Include sizes 3-8. I made a size 8 since I wanted it big and didn't want my daughter to out grow it before she got any use.
Did it look like the photo/drawing on the pattern envelope once you were done sewing with it? Yes
Were the instructions easy to follow? Yes
What did you particularly like or dislike about the pattern? It was easy to make.
Fabric Used: Babyville PUL which is great from protecting clothes from getting wet when a child is painting. I think with this fabric 1/2" bias tape may have been better, especially for the bottom where you have two layers of the fabric.
Pattern alterations or any design changes you made: I don't like ties on children's items since they always come undone, so I omitted the ties and added a magnetic snap. But that was too heavy for the fabric and when trying to separate the snap the fabric was getting stretched out. So I removed the snaps and added Velcro. If you are not using the ties then you only need one pack of bias tape. I actually had 6" left from the 1st pack and didn't open the 2nd.
Would you sew it again? Would you recommend it to others? Yes. I am going to make my son one. I might make it a little longer since he is bigger than my daughter, but since he is so skinny I don't think I need to adjust any other parts of it.
Conclusion: Great pattern for a smock, although I wonder why they recommend cotton fabrics instead of the various waterproof fabrics available.