I made the skirt with fly front and pockets and cut the 10 which worked well. It did look like the photo but I had actually chosen it because of the pattern line drawing, which was a bit misleading.
As usual I messed up inserting the zip when following the pattern instructions. To me, there seems to be a step missing. Maybe it's me! Also the waistband instructions didn't correspond to the waistband pieces. I also didn't understand why you had to add ease at the top of the skirt because I just ended up with a fullness at the waistband that looked wrong.
Good things? The skirt has turned out to be really useful and comfortable. I liked the little extra tips throughout the instructions.
Bad things? The skirt is actually quite short and the usual alteration I make for my height made it on the verge of being a mini. The pockets are a bit nippy. They'll take a phone but only just. The design is quite dated in its style as the waistaband comes up very high. I'm not sure you'd find a RTW skirt with such a high rise these days.
Fabric Used:Stretch Cotton polyester with 3% Lycra from John Lewis (half price in the sale). I had only bought 70cm and this turned out to be just enough.
Like a lot of the other sewists on Pattern Review I substituted the main fabric with a lighter weight material for the waistband and pocket facing although in my case that was because I'd been too mean to buy more fabric.
I will sew it again and would definitely use stretch fabric. I would also use the very good advice about improving the pocket instruction that you can find here: http://the-diligent-dilettante.blogspot.co.uk/2012_08_01_archive.html. Another valuable blog post is on sewamysew.com
Buy this pattern for $15.96 List Price: $19.95Add to Bag