Over 20,000 of high quality reorderable fabric
SIGNUP - FREE Membership & 1 FREE Sewing Lesson
Enter your e-mail address:
New to PR?
Compare Sewing Machines
Sewing Machine & Serger Reviews
Sewing Class Reviews
Sewing Expo Reviews
Sewing Tips & Techniques
Sewing Review Requests
Add a Review Request
Friends of PR
Join Friends of PR
Find a member
Add a Classified
reviews with comments
returns & refunds
Platinum Sponsor -
Master Pattern Book
No Time To Sew
8 more reviews
by 2 people
by 15 people
Member since: 3/21/02
Report a problem with this review
8/15/02 12:50 PM
6/24/03 7:34 PM
To read this review, please
. Only registered members can read reviews written more than 6 months ago.
Pattern with more than 5 reviews!
Merchants on PR
Elliott Berman Textiles
Fabrics for Greater Ideas
Sewn Square One
Patterns for Your Style.
Fabric Shopping Help!
Login to Add a Comment
Wow! This is great! I will DEFINITELY be using the measuring tape a lot when I try any of these! Thank you so much for your very involved and very thoughtful review!
8/15/02 2:28 PM
Mini, I agree with you on these patterns. Just because they are by Sandra Betzina, whom I love, I think these patterns should be passed over. I think I would have to make too many changes and would rather spend my time on garments that are more up to date and stylish than these.
8/15/02 2:36 PM
Mini, as usual you have provided us with a very comprehensive review. I purchased this book/pattern set because I liked the tuxedo shirt (I didn't know the patterns were available separately). I will keep your recommendations in mind if I decide I still want to make it.
8/15/02 3:10 PM
Mini, you have made a huge favor to all of us, thank you very much!!
8/15/02 3:55 PM
If you are ever looking for work, NYT could use you as a book reviewer. Thanks for the thorough reviews you always write for us.
8/15/02 4:41 PM
Veryb well done, Mini. I have the book and pattern set also and had varying success with garments that I made from it; (the slim pants fit me like leggings, too). My biggest disappointment was that the illustrations on the pattern envelope did not match the garments themselves. The vest is probably the worst of the lot on that; it absolutely does not resemble the illustration at all. But the book is inspiring nonetheless -- I think it's due to Sandra's encouraging writing style -- and I'm glad I've got it.
8/15/02 5:21 PM
I agree with CatherineN! But for now I am just very very happy that Mini is reviewing for us :o)
8/15/02 6:17 PM
Excellent review, Mini. I appreciate your taking the time to do such a thorough review. I have this book but haven't sewn anything from it yet. Your comments will be very helpful for when I do.
8/15/02 7:59 PM
Great review Mini you have written and excellent review . I too have the book and pattern just have not make anything from them yet. After reading your review I will take a lot of work to use these patterns would probably be worth in for the shirt. The others I may pass on.
8/15/02 9:35 PM
Thank you Mini! I too had the book and the pattern (and gave away both). The vest, I made in the smallest size, came out very boxy and overwhelming for my figure (I am small and thin), perhaps because of the shape of the front parts. I found it unwearable. I agree with Lisa Laree that the illustration looks very different. Sandra's garments mostly rely on the wonderful fabrics she uses and the beautiful photographs, I guess. As an entertaining read I liked the book though.
8/16/02 1:18 AM
I made the tuxedo shirt years ago in a soft small wale corduroy...I loved the fit, the collar was perfect and didn't feel too high for me, so check for your own preferences. I have used this type of sleeve closing in just about every shirt/blouse since.
8/18/02 1:20 AM
Mini, I wish I had this review to read last year when I first purchased the book.Would have saved a lot of time and fabric wasted. I tried, both pants, tee shirt, and gored skirt and was not happy with any of them.KUTGW
8/20/02 7:35 PM
Wow! This was exactly my experience with these patterns! I have spent so much time trying to tweak them to look like the photos and I am always discouraged! I thought it was just me! I like the slim pants pattern but that was it. I'm short and fairly small so the t-shirt dwarfed me as well as the full pants. They made me look like my waist was up around my armpits. I love Sandra Betzina, though, so I enjoyed the book. I think I really like the styles but I am too short to wear them.
10/10/02 4:27 PM
Mini, I had not seen this review. I'm glad it showed up at the top of the list again. I had thought about buying this to try out some new techniques but it sounds like this book would not really serve that purpose.
2/3/03 0:45 AM
I bought this book/patterns because I love the way Sandra Betzina teaches,she is very inspiring. I made the tuxedo shirt and like it very much, I found the sleeves on the short side but since I usually need to add to the sleeve lenght it might be just that. I'm sorry to hear about the other patterns I was going to try the dress next.
2/3/03 6:19 PM
Thanks for your review. I totally agree with your comments on the tuxedo shirt collar, wish I'd done something different with mine. Every time I wear it I have makeup on the collar. I also found the sleeves short, weird for me as I am very short. I did find that the gored skirt pattern was a dream I have made it 6 times and still love the way it fits. The full pants are lovely but not for me except on extra fluffy days. I had to shorten the crotch more than 2 inches. All that in mind, it still is a really good book.
6/25/03 2:12 PM
I think I am the only one who likes the slim/tapered leg pants. I followed her directions for the tummy alteration and added 6 inches for my tummy. I forget if it was 6 inches total or 6 inches/pattern piece. She has you do this by slicing the pattern all the way down the leg. It worked for me, and I really like the pants. Of course, 6 inches is a tremendous amount to add, and adding those 6 inches at the tummy also added a lot at the thigh. That being said, I haven't made that many of these because of the lack of pocket.
6/25/03 5:07 PM
Thank you, thank you and thank you. I have had this book and patterns for a long time and just couldn't get excited enough to attempt sewing anything up. Could be because I knew that a 'fluffy petitte' should steer away from the tapered pants even when she wants them to look as good on her as they do in the book! I may try the T shirt with your modifications and the Tuxedo shirt is still tempting me . . . I still want to justify buying the set to begin with - better than lamenting time and fabric on something I wouldn't be able to wear, thanks.
11/21/03 11:54 AM
Mini--Thank you for this review. I'm in the process of making the slim pants and I can't get them up over my hips. So, obviously, I read something into the instructions that was different than Sandra Betzina's intent, so I came here for help. I made the full pants and like the look, but found that I needed to shorten the crotch quite a bit, too. I'll follow the suggestions from Mini and others for any other patterns that I try--such as the T-shirt. Thanks so much for your comments. This is EXACTLY what I wanted to know. Thanks again.
9/26/04 7:41 AM
I love your reviews and if I see you have reviewed a pattern, yours is the first I click on. I too have this book. I agree with your assesment. The T was too boxy, the pants too tight, and the raglan dress needed lots of alterations. I made the raglan sleeve dress out of some stretch velour and had a bitch of a time with the underarms. Unfortunately I cut the pattern since the underarms hung to my waist. I had never made 2 piece raglan sleeves before or since. I did like the dress but it has gone to the wayside years ago. And thanks for the advice with the scarves. Maybe that is why I don't like scarves. They have always been square. I think I will pull out the book and make a few. Might as well get my moneys worth. He hee.
11/4/04 11:35 PM
Thanks for this terrific review...I am making the wide pants first. I got the book recently at a closeout vendor (no paterns in it), and then ordered the patterns from Betzina's online store. I am certainly going to print your review and leave in the book permanently. I hope to try the tuxedo shirt.
9/25/06 1:55 PM
Mini, your reviews keep on giving! I've read this one a number of times over the years, but it was just today, in trying to decide on a pants pattern and thinking about the SB full pants, that I noticed you mention Burda 4550 here. A light went on! This was the very first pattern I ever tried and had stuffed it away because I was so discouraged by my poor sewing skills at the time. I just went and dug it out and I'm going to try it again. It could be that the pattern I've been searching for has been hiding on a shelf all this time! THANK YOU!
10/17/06 2:05 PM
thank you for the great review..just found my patterns while cleaning the closet & am going to try some of the patterns, so your comments are helpful particulary on the gored skirt & tuxedo blouse.
4/2/07 10:44 PM
Online Sewing Classes
Fun with Fitting - BODICE w Darts
Online Sewing Classes
Beginners Guide to Dyeing Fabrics
Char in KS
Sewing Workshop 8th Avenue Skirt Pattern
Add to Bag
Favorite Things The Frayed Jacket Pattern
Add to Bag
Blank Slate Quilted Camera Bag Digital Pattern
Add to Bag
Peek-A Boo Floppy Flower Sun Hat Digital Pattern ( Size newborn - child )
Add to Bag
You Sew Girl PFKSHELC
Butterick 5529 Pattern ( Size XSM-SML-MED )
Add to Bag
Simplicity 4927 Pattern( Size 3-4-5-6-7-8 )
Add to Bag
Copyright © 2014 PatternReview.com® , OSATech, Inc. All rights reserved.
Conditions of Use