Sponsors
Sponsors
Sizing Accuracy (Moderated by Deepika, EleanorSews)
Posted on: 12/17/09 8:57 AM ET
I love looking at the My Shape website for ideas but for the first time I actually found something I really want. Plus, they are having a 40% off sale for sweaters (nayy).
Anyway, how accurate is their choice of sizing for you if you've filled out all their measurements? Anyone order and have good/bad luck with it?
The one sweater I want, they say to get an XL. All their other stuff for me is a M or L. I haven't been an XL in a long time and the sweater is a wrap type and I'm worried if it's too big it will be too low.

------
Anyway, how accurate is their choice of sizing for you if you've filled out all their measurements? Anyone order and have good/bad luck with it?
The one sweater I want, they say to get an XL. All their other stuff for me is a M or L. I haven't been an XL in a long time and the sweater is a wrap type and I'm worried if it's too big it will be too low.

------
http://kimsewsilly.blogspot.com/
Posted on: 12/17/09 12:16 PM ET
In reply to Kim12469
Can't help you with sizing, ordering, etc but wanted to say that's a great sweater! Maybe you should order one for me, too?!
Anne
Anne
Posted on: 12/17/09 12:26 PM ET
I've ordered from them. Sorry to say, it's been hit or miss with the sizing. Although they do try to advise if one ought to size up or size down with a particular designer, I've had to send some things back because they were too small or large.
That looks like a nice sweater - you could give it a try. MyShape is very good with returns!
That looks like a nice sweater - you could give it a try. MyShape is very good with returns!
Posted on: 12/17/09 12:40 PM ET
In reply to Kim12469
Quote: Kim12469
Anyway, how accurate is their choice of sizing for you if you've filled out all their measurements? The one sweater I want, they say to get an XL. All their other stuff for me is a M or L. I haven't been an XL in a long time
Anyway, how accurate is their choice of sizing for you if you've filled out all their measurements? The one sweater I want, they say to get an XL. All their other stuff for me is a M or L. I haven't been an XL in a long time
Sizing will vary because they're retailing products from a variety of manufacturers.
------
http://fashion-incubator.com
Lessons from the sustainable sewing factory floor
Lessons from the sustainable sewing factory floor
Posted on: 12/17/09 12:48 PM ET
In reply to Kathleen Fasanella
Yes, I understand that, but the last time I was in any XL anything was about 40 pounds heavier.
Also, the other things suggested from this designer show me at a Large, which is more reasonable. I'm usually in between M and L.
------
Also, the other things suggested from this designer show me at a Large, which is more reasonable. I'm usually in between M and L.
------
http://kimsewsilly.blogspot.com/
Posted on: 12/17/09 2:12 PM ET
Everything my daughter has ordered from them has fit. She has even ordered jeans! I have only ordered 2 tops and one pair linen pants. One top was much tighter and more revealing than I am comfortable wearing. It fit, but was not my personal taste. I liked the other two items.
Posted on: 12/17/09 3:27 PM ET
Very nice sweater!
The only things I ordered from them (some pants back a few years ago) were definitely the correct size for me (based on their suggestions).
Doesn't sound like it has worked out that well for everyone, though.
------
The only things I ordered from them (some pants back a few years ago) were definitely the correct size for me (based on their suggestions).
Doesn't sound like it has worked out that well for everyone, though.
------
With a great wardrobe that's still in the flat-fabric stage.
Posted on: 12/17/09 9:34 PM ET
In reply to Kim12469
If doing a return isn't a major hassle for you (and the initial shipping charge isn't outrageous) order the size you think you need, one smaller, and one larger. Return what doesn't fit. I do this to avoid having to return, reorder, and then have the item possibly be out of stock.
HTH
Anne
HTH
Anne
Posted on: 12/18/09 12:47 PM ET
I've purchased several things from them, tops, sweaters, dresses, jeans, pants and jackets. All of them fit nicely. I think the key is to include All your measurements and then hit the "go sizeless" button. They compare the garment measurements and tell you whether or not it will fit or if it isn't recommended for your body type.
------
------
Sandra
Whatever You Can Do, or Dream You Can, Begin it, Boldness has Genious, Power and Magic in it. - Goethe
Whatever You Can Do, or Dream You Can, Begin it, Boldness has Genious, Power and Magic in it. - Goethe
Posted on: 12/18/09 12:57 PM ET
I agree to go with their sizing. They know what runs large and what runs small...since we know not all sizes are equal and that is the premise for their company philosophy. Their goal is to make online shopping easier on the sizing end. Few if any companies ask for your sizing...they do.
I just went through a customer service snaffu with them and at the end...they more than made up for my inconvenience on an out-of-stock item. (I wasn't notified when something was out of stock). They were short handed and the rep who finally "got me" was very calm, helpful and wanted to keep me.
I do recommend them and have been happy with previous orders. I will order again. By the way...I wear any size from a Med to an XLarge in r-t-w. It's all how my bust fits...I don't like things too tight or too loose.
I just went through a customer service snaffu with them and at the end...they more than made up for my inconvenience on an out-of-stock item. (I wasn't notified when something was out of stock). They were short handed and the rep who finally "got me" was very calm, helpful and wanted to keep me.
I do recommend them and have been happy with previous orders. I will order again. By the way...I wear any size from a Med to an XLarge in r-t-w. It's all how my bust fits...I don't like things too tight or too loose.
* Advertising and soliciting is strictly prohibited on PatternReview.com. If you find a post which is not in agreement with our Terms and Conditions, please click on the Report Post button to report it.
Selected Reviews, Classes & Patterns







